CHAPTER 22: AREA 51 AND THE ROAD APPLE TO ROSWELL

Mark was furious. He had just finished reading Area 51 by Annie Jacobsen and couldn’t believe what he’d read. Technically, she had the history mostly right—much of it drawn from open sources that had already written about Area 51, and often done so more convincingly. But the final chapter stunned him. It relied on an alleged insider who claimed that the Roswell crash was actually a Soviet intelligence operation involving genetically altered children created by Nazi doctor Josef Mengele. In Mark’s opinion, Jacobsen had been completely duped, but more than that, she had kicked dirt in the already polluted ocean of myths about Roswell. 

He sent me a copy of the book and asked me to write an honest review on Black Horizon. He was right, the ending was pure unadulterated shit. It read to me like a PsyOp. 

"Fuck Area 51 he said. A new narrative on Roswell only makes things harder. We have our work cut out for us." 

Yes, Jacobsen did have a genuine insider who provided her with older Cold War–era information about the base—most notably Thornton T. Barnes. That material had real value. But everything beyond that was pure nonsense. By the end, it was clear that all Jacobsen had accomplished was to muddy the truth about Roswell beyond recognition. The final chapter was a farce—some convoluted intelligence-agency concoction swallowed whole. She drank the Kool-Aid as if it were free champagne.

I don’t even need to write a detailed review of Annie Jacobsen’s Area 51: Uncensored to offer simple advice: if you’re tempted to buy it in hopes of discovering the “truth” about the world’s worst-kept secret base, just keep walking. You won’t find it here.

What you will find is a book riddled with historical errors and so-called “insider information” that makes Bob Lazar’s aliens-at-Area-51 stories look almost plausible by comparison.

But don’t take my word for it. Just read the following excerpt from a recent NPR interview with Jacobsen, and you’ll quickly understand why this book qualifies as yet another epic fail.

“The Horten brothers were involved in the flying disc crash in New Mexico. And that is from a single source. … There was an unusual moment where that source became very upset and told me things that were stunning—almost impossible to believe at first read. And that is that a flying disc really did crash in New Mexico and it was transported to Wright-Patterson Air Force Base, and then in 1951 it was transferred to Area 51, which is why the base is called Area 51.”

Jacobsen goes on to explain that her source claimed the craft contained “child-sized pilots,” whom he believed to be around 13 years old, and that these individuals were the result of a Soviet human experimentation program designed to make them resemble aliens—a black-propaganda operation allegedly meant to terrify the United States during the early Cold War.

She further suggests that Josef Mengele, the Nazi doctor infamous for his crimes during World War II, had survived the collapse of the Third Reich and was secretly working with Stalin on these experiments.

According to Jacobsen, this extraordinary story comes from a single unnamed source whose account she says she “absolutely believes,” despite acknowledging how implausible and alarming it sounds.

This is where Area 51: Uncensored finally derails completely.

What Jacobsen presents as a stunning revelation reads instead like an intelligence-community fever dream stitched together from Cold War paranoia, UFO mythology, and speculative timeline-fitting. The idea that the Roswell incident was a Soviet hoax involving surgically altered children, Nazi scientists, and flying discs is not supported by corroborating evidence, documentation, or credible secondary sources. It is conjecture elevated to conclusion.

Journalistic skepticism is abandoned in favor of belief. One source becomes the explanation. And readers are asked to accept an extraordinary claim on faith alone.

In the end, this book doesn’t uncover hidden truths about Area 51—it obscures them. Whatever serious history Jacobsen might have told is buried beneath sensationalism and a story that collapses under even light scrutiny.

— Steve Douglass
Deep Black Horizon

By contrast, a far better and genuinely comprehensive account would later be published by one of the true core interceptors of the Area 51 story: Peter Merlin. Unlike sensationalist narratives built around single anonymous sources, Merlin’s work is grounded in meticulous research, primary documentation, and decades of direct engagement with the history of classified aviation programs. His approach is disciplined and methodical, focused on verifiable facts rather than speculation, and it places Area 51 squarely in its real historical context—as a testing ground for advanced aircraft, not a repository for fantastical myths. Where others blur the line between evidence and imagination, Merlin draws it clearly, producing a work that informs rather than obscures.

What bothered Mark most were her claims about Roswell—not just because they were obviously dead wrong, but because he knew exactly what would happen next. Another neatly packaged myth had been released into the world, and it would cling stubbornly to the story, immune to evidence, corrections, or context. 

No matter how often it was challenged, it would be repeated, misquoted, and recycled until this bollocks  hardened into “common knowledge.” The truth would once again be buried under a louder, more seductive fiction, and Roswell—already distorted beyond recognition—would be reduced further to a punchline wrapped in pseudo-history. What angered him wasn’t just the carelessness of the claim, but the certainty that it would stick, like glue, long after the facts had been ignored and the damage done.

On the flipside, it became even more important to Mark to get the real truth about Roswell out into the open. He warned me that people might not like it—or even believe it. The real story wasn’t sexy, sensational, or easy to digest, but it was grounded in the methods and rigor of real science. It wouldn’t be popular, but it would make sense. Jacobsen had only made Roswell harder to understand, muddying the waters with her tall tale, which meant we would have to work even harder to polish that turd and present the facts clearly.

He asked me if I was up to it. It would take some work to simplify the data so that a normal person could actually understand it. The real story of Roswell relied on a knowledge of absolutes, grounded in the scientific laws that govern how the universe works. "If you were hoping it could be turned into a Hollywood-style blockbuster, think again. The truth isn’t cinematic. It isn’t flashy. It is precise, logical, and rooted in mathematics—far less glamorous, but far more real." It goes far beyond little green men and anything Jacobsen could imagine. There is no simple Hollywood trope that can capture Roswell. Understanding it is a journey—but one that demands a sober, scientific mind, not one given to fantasy or sensationalism."

UP NEXT: THE UNIVERSE IS UNDER NO OBLIGATION TO MAKE SENSE TO YOU